Unexpected Result During Fire Resistance Test (final Test)

by DuralM in Workshop > Molds & Casting

4092 Views, 31 Favorites, 0 Comments

Unexpected Result During Fire Resistance Test (final Test)

Unexpected results during fire resistance test (part 2)

That’s the second part of refractories test. After that test I will choose the best material for my new metal melting furnace project. This particular experiment consists of 2 smaller tests

Proportions for the First Test

Unexpected results during fire resistance test.avi_snapshot_00.05_[2016.11.15_19.59.12].jpg
Unexpected results during fire resistance test.avi_snapshot_00.28_[2016.11.15_19.59.57].jpg

During the first test, I made such mixtures:

1. Fire clay – 100%;

2. Fire clay – 40%; Grog – 40%; Graphite dust – 20%

3. Fire clay – 40%; Grog – 50%; Graphite dust – 10%

4. Fire clay 40%; Grog – 50%; Graphite dust – 5%; Mineral wool – 5%

5. Fire clay – 40% Grog – 40%; Graphite dust – 10%; Alabaster – 10%

6. Alabaster – 50%; Sand – 50%;

7. Cement – 50%; Sand – 50%

Drying Into the Oven

Unexpected results during fire resistance test.avi_snapshot_00.33_[2016.11.15_20.00.10].jpg

I put samples into the oven to dry them:

- 5 hours +50 C° (122F°);

- 2 hours +100+180 C° (212-356 F°);

- 2 hours +250 C° (482 F°).

After the Oven Drying

Unexpected results during fire resistance test.avi_snapshot_00.43_[2016.11.15_20.00.29].jpg

All samples survived except one. Sample #6 (Alabaster/Sand – 50/50%) was damaged during the air drying.

Testing With a Torch

Unexpected results during fire resistance test.avi_snapshot_01.09_[2016.11.15_20.01.43].jpg
Unexpected results during fire resistance test.avi_snapshot_01.15_[2016.11.15_20.01.58].jpg

First part of the test was with gasoline torch. During it samples didn’t get any damages.

Testing in the Melting Furnace

Unexpected results during fire resistance test.avi_snapshot_01.38_[2016.11.15_20.02.28].jpg
Unexpected results during fire resistance test.avi_snapshot_01.46_[2016.11.15_20.02.46].jpg
Unexpected results during fire resistance test.avi_snapshot_01.54_[2016.11.15_20.02.59].jpg
Unexpected results during fire resistance test.avi_snapshot_01.59_[2016.11.15_20.03.09].jpg
Unexpected results during fire resistance test.avi_snapshot_02.57_[2016.11.15_20.04.13].jpg
Unexpected results during fire resistance test.avi_snapshot_03.07_[2016.11.15_20.04.27].jpg
Unexpected results during fire resistance test.avi_snapshot_03.16_[2016.11.15_20.04.44].jpg

Second part of the test in the smelting furnace was much more destructive. The process took about an hour. In my opinion, the temperature was more than 1200 C° (2192 F°). All samples were damaged. Only the sample #3 got minor damages. Therefore, in this test it’s the best result.

Nevertheless, the sample #7 (cement/sand – 50/50%) was damaged but held the shape. Therefore, I wanted to make one more test where cement could be one of the main ingredients.

Second Test Samples

Unexpected results during fire resistance test.avi_snapshot_03.29_[2016.11.15_20.05.14].jpg
Unexpected results during fire resistance test.avi_snapshot_03.45_[2016.11.15_20.05.34].jpg

During the second test, I made samples:

1. Cement – 50%; Sand – 25%; Grog – 25%;

2. Cement – 50%; Fire clay – 25%; Grog – 25%;

3. Cement – 40%; Sand – 17.5%; Grog – 15; Fire clay – 27.5%;

4. Cement – 22.5%; Sand – 27.5%; Grog – 22.5%; Fire clay – 27.5%;

5. Cement – 22.5%; Sand – 22.5%; Grog – 22.5%; Fire clay – 27.5%; Graphite dust -5%

All steps of the process were the same as in the first experiment.

Melting

Unexpected results during fire resistance test.avi_snapshot_04.17_[2016.11.15_20.06.36].jpg
Unexpected results during fire resistance test.avi_snapshot_04.29_[2016.11.15_20.06.52].jpg
Unexpected results during fire resistance test.avi_snapshot_04.38_[2016.11.15_20.07.08].jpg

Finally, in the smelting furnace samples started melting. I think that the problem is the sand and the cement.

Final Results

Unexpected results during fire resistance test.avi_snapshot_04.42_[2016.11.15_20.07.15].jpg
Unexpected results during fire resistance test.avi_snapshot_04.59_[2016.11.15_20.07.38].jpg
Unexpected results during fire resistance test.avi_snapshot_05.07_[2016.11.15_20.07.50].jpg

I used the river sand and not the silica sand. Silica sand as I now sustain much higher temperatures than river sand.

I’ve made a decision to use fire clay/grog/graphite dust (40/50/10%) in my new furnace.