The Official Guide to Knex Ball Machine Path Selectors

by mathsboy314 in Living > LEGO & K'NEX

15262 Views, 30 Favorites, 0 Comments

The Official Guide to Knex Ball Machine Path Selectors

infinity2.png
Just like there's a guide for building ball machines and ball lifts, I decided to make one for path separators. This will go through all types of path separators with details including paths, height lost, a video and instructions if any.











Vertical Path Separator

vertical2.jpg
vertical.jpg
The most common ball switch: the vertical path separator!

Tracks: 2
Height: 1 blue rod
Video: Almost any ball machine
Instructions: Just see the pictures


(Pictures: RNBShadowman39)

Horizontal Path Separator

horizontal2.jpg
horizontal.jpg
horizontal.PNG
horizontal.jpg
This is the vertical path separator, except horizontal to save height.

Tracks: 2
Height: tilted ramp for momentum
Video: A lot of ball machines, here's one (0:24)
Instructions: Just see the pictures


(Pictures: Darth Trainman, Shadowman39, knexknexknexknex, collinjo12)

Giant Car Switch

car.PNG
car2.PNG
car3.PNG
Build by Darth Trainman and probably fifth cousins with the vertical path separator, this has a ball-gravity powered car which changes it's side of the entrance track each time a ball lands on it.

Tracks: 2
Height: 2 red rods
Video: Seen in Project 360 (2:46)

Infinity Switch

infinity2.png
infinity.png
FHV3S6TINRJ9YSP_LARGE.jpg
FYWHARWINRJ9YRS_LARGE.jpg

Sorunome's redo of YardKing's version allows many paths coming out of this ball separator.

Tracks: infinity (but no-ones ever tested)
Height: 1 Blue rod + tilt for momentum
Video: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1WP-c4BjMmY
Instructions: https://www.instructables.com/id/Knex-Ball-Machine-Elemenit-Infinity-Switch/

Bezempje95's Infinite Switch

bezempje2.jpg
bezempje.png
A lot like the infinity switch, except more complicated, and proper scaffold.

Tracks: As many as you want
Height: 1 blue rod + tilt for momentum
Video: www.youtube.com/watch?v=LfatMtT_IXI
Instructions: None yet, but here are a lot of pictures:
https://www.instructables.com/id/My-collinjo12-guide-to-KNEX-Ball-Machine-Element/step54/Path-Separator/

Shadow Separator

FB4ZR5YHTQN6MC1_MEDIUM.jpg
F1D27YRHTQN6MCS_MEDIUM.jpg
F9ZMI5XHTQN6MEQ_MEDIUM.jpg

Sandroknexmaster made his version of the infinity switch, where a ball activates a motor at the end.

Tracks: As many as you like
Height: Tilt for momentum
Video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3B0PKqlQx7I
Instructions: https://www.instructables.com/id/Shadow-Separator-a-knex-ball-machine-path-separato/

Leapfrog Separator

leapfrog.jpg

Sandroknexmaster also made the leapfrog separator, which is kinda similar to the previous step except all the balls are released at the same time.

Tracks: As many as you like

Height: 3 Green Rods + 1 Green Rod per Track

Video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EtPe_q9TV9g

Instructions: https://www.instructables.com/id/Leapfrog-Separato...

Circular Path Separator

Shadowman.PNG
Shadowman2.PNG

Shadowman39 built a curved path with barriers that push the ball out the way, which also get raised and lowered.

Tracks: 10 in example, but can be increased
Height: 1 red rod
Video: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hBJBwLS1Ijc

Orange Slide Path Switch

FH1ML20ILQTDNC0_MEDIUM.jpg
FMPMZMIILJSI7TE_MEDIUM.jpg

This switch is a remix of the horizontal path separator and a module of the infinity switch. It was built by Mmtunligit.

Tracks: 2

Height: 1 blue rod

Instructions: https://www.instructables.com/id/Knex-Orange-Slide-Path-Switch/

Barrel Roll

RIMG0067.JPG
RIMG0061.JPG
RIMG0062.JPG
RIMG0064.JPG
RIMG0065.JPG
RIMG0066.JPG
RIMG0063.JPG
RIMG0068.JPG
RIMG0069.JPG
RIMG0070.JPG

Each ball releases the previous ball, then gets caught in a different position. While doing this, the mechanism rotates 90 degrees.

Tracks: 2
Height: 1 red rod
Video: Explained in this ball machine (0:32)
Instructions: Follow the pictures

Thibault's Switch

houurf'hnw.PNG
houurf'hnw2.PNG

Thibault made a switch which is a mix between the 'Infinity Switch', 'Mechanical Dizzy', and the 'Barrel Role'. It uses a Ferris wheel element connected to small barriers positioned across a track.

Tracks: 8
Height: 1 red rod (+ tilt for momentum)
Video: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ISlkZ2mMBCM

Quad Switch

F6CRXS6I9SBRDJ4.LARGE[1].jpg

collinjo12 Made a smaller version of Thibaults's separator.

Tracks: 4

Height:

Video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y17Um0F5gzI

Instructions: https://www.instructables.com/id/Quad-Switch-Knex-Path-Separator/

Mechanical Dizzy

dizzy.PNG
F6VGM1GHMFQKROA_RECTANGLE1.jpg
dizzy3.PNG

Featured in project ARCANE by Yardking, this has a small Ferris wheel element geared to a path that turns around.

Tracks: 8
Height: 1.5 red rods
Instructions: See YardKing's comment below. (Remember, his version is for golf balls, so the entrance at the top [tagged in first pic] needs extra space.)

Octoswitch

FALUJMOHZ3YCAXO_MEDIUM.jpg
F4HPK2PHZ3YCAZP_MEDIUM.jpg

Caverat built this separator. This is an inconsistent separator, as it relies on a motor spinning which a ball lands on, then rolls to the side.

Tracks: 8

Height: 3 blue rods

Video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A4bcZbW7qfk

Instructions: https://www.instructables.com/id/Octoswitch-a-Knex-path-separator/

Trainman's Switch

train2.PNG
train.PNG
train3.PNG
Darth Trainman made a separator that's like mechanical dizzy, this uses a spinning element to push a double path back and forth, changing which path the ball goes on.

Tracks: 2 (but can probably be modified)
Height: 1 red rod
Video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NdmFTE_1qU4 (3:54)

Rotating Crane Arm

FQVB9USHJUWSVAB.LARGE.jpg
FR7NYK1HJUWSVD7.LARGE.jpg
F4NJSHMHJUWSVBN.LARGE.jpg
FTC4C61HJUWSVGT.LARGE.jpg
MechanicalCreationMaster built this switch in his ball machine "Erection". The ball machine waits in the middle for a path to arrive, then the ball goes down it. Each path should differ so the ball goes in different directions.

Tracks: As many as you want, if it fits.
Height: Tilt for momentum, or have elements
More pictures: https://www.instructables.com/id/Knex-Ball-Machine-Erection/step2/Path-Separators/

Motorized Tilting Panel

tilt.PNG
tilt2.PNG
In the ball machine Tartarus by Alocke, the path separator for network 2 is a panel that tilts like 'circle ball machine'.
Do not use with other crankshaft lifts that run at the same speed.

Tracks: 4 (can be modified)
Height: 1 red rod

Tilting Panel

4way.jpg

By Shadowman39, this is a small panel with 4 exits, each one leading to a lever that shifts the panel's direction. Explanation as tags in the picture.

Tracks: 4
Height: 1 red rod
Video: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rugwVv6ZZsA

2 Way Panel Separator

FZ9DGFJK66891I5.LARGE.jpg

This version of the Tilting Panel Separator is made by Borisv9. It has less paths than Shadowman's version, and is a lot more compact.

Tracks: 2

Height: 1 Blue rod

Video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IAPyLNLodao

Instructions: https://www.instructables.com/id/Knex-2-Way-Panel-Separator/

3-Way Geartrain Switch

FMV3OKEJ8YR8GWI.MEDIUM.jpg
F1AGGYJJ8YR8GWM.MEDIUM.jpg

This switch was built by Mmtunligit, it evenly divides three balls by combining the vertical path separator and the barrel roll.

Tracks: 3

Height: 3 blue rods

Video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mitgAJy3ra8

Instructions: https://www.instructables.com/id/Knex-3-Way-Geartrain-Switch/

YSL's 6-way Ball Separator

medium.jpg

This switch was built by YoloSweggLord. It has two 3-way ball separators connected to a frame, and the frame tilts to change which side the ball goes to.

Tracks: 6

Height: 3 blue rods

Instructions: https://knexflux.net/instructions/ysl's-6-way-ball...

Double Drop and a Reset

RIMG0174.JPG
RIMG0175.JPG
RIMG0177.JPG
RIMG0176.JPG

Best used with other switches, this switch I made first saves one ball, the second sets it off, and the third resets the switch.
Thibault also made a version, probably earlier, in his ball machine 'the Millenium' (2:00).

Tracks: 3
Height: 1 red rod
Video: Seen in this ball machine (1:45)
Instructions: Just look at pictures

Stacker Separator

FEZ53P6HR4SWKK7.MEDIUM.jpg
FYT9OQNHR4SWKL0.MEDIUM.jpg
tri.PNG
Sandroknexmaster made another a version of the last step in his ball machine 'Paradox' (1:36), except it saves 2, and the third ball releases all the balls.

Tracks: 3
Height: 1 red rod
Video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dPcrNoxN0V0
Instructions: https://www.instructables.com/id/Stacker-Separator-a-knex-ball-machine-path-separat/



Raiser Lift

raiser.jpg
raiser2.jpg

A ball lift I attempted to make but had no proper entrance track mechanism, making it consistently inconsistent.
Do not use with other crankshaft lifts that run at the same speed.

Tracks: 2
Height: -1 red rod (ball goes up or down)
Video: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I-WB3c2Y4RA
Instructions: https://www.instructables.com/id/Knex-Raiser-Lift/

Lifts With Multiple Exit Tracks

18.jpg
RIMG0188.JPG
RIMG0189.JPG

Lifts such as the chain lift (including most modifications) and the quadruple arm lift have different ways of holding the ball, and different places to hold to ball, meaning the ball can fall off at either point.

(Pictures: collinjo12, mathsboy314)

Separating Arm Lift

arm lift.jpg
arm lift2.jpg

This lift is similar to the quadruple arm lift, except the separator is in the arms instead of the hands. When the ball reaches the top of the lift, it rolls down the arm, and falls off at a different point in each arm.

Tracks: 8

Height: -6 to -10 red rods (it is a lift)

Video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cTLSKf1oqyI

Instructions: https://www.instructables.com/id/Separating-Arm-Li...

Inconsistent Elements

inconsistent3.jpg
inconsistent2.jpg
inconsistent.jpg
FQUKOA2H1JUGXB3_LARGE.jpg

If the ball element doesn't always land in the same place, it can classify as a ball switch.


(Pictures: KneXtreme, Shadowman39, Darth Trainman, Sandroknexmaster)

Elements That Don't Reset Instantly

RIMG0180.JPG
RIMG0179.JPG
reset.PNG
reset2.PNG

If the element doesn't reset, the next ball probably wont go the same way as the first ball. For it to be a proper path selector, one of the balls must reset it. (Almost all basic 2-path switches would fall under this category.)

Compact Separator

FL2RGFGIFO70BFX_LARGE.jpg

This is another element that doesn't reset instantly, built by www139. This separator is convenient because the entrance track is a basic ball machine path.

Tracks: 2
Height: 1 Blue rod
Video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FJCJdsscgJs

Instructions: https://www.instructables.com/id/Compact-Separator-a-Knex-ball-machine-separator

Ball Waiter

wait.PNG

When a ball is waiting to enter an area (e.g. lift) and a new ball comes around, instead of joining the queue it can roll to the side instead.
Do not use with lifts that quickly collect balls

Tracks: 2
Height: tilt for momentum
Video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=owQMRP64UrM


(Picture: Sorunome)

Double Drop

RIMG0181.JPG
RIMG0182.JPG
RIMG0184.JPG
wball.PNG
This element starts from one path but because it has room for two balls, the ball go to separate areas. This is idea has been mainly used in Project 360.

Quadruple Drop

4ball.jpg
Like the double drop, but with 4 balls.

Tracks: 4
Height: 1 blue rod
Instructions: https://www.instructables.com/id/Knex-Ball-Machine-Dragonfire-new-elements/step5/Four-balls-divider/

Other Multiball Elements

multiball3.PNG
multiball4.PNG
RIMG0190.JPG
RIMG0191.JPG
RIMG0192.JPG
RIMG0193.JPG
2ball.jpg
multiball5.PNG
24.jpg
If the element originates from a single track, but the balls head to different areas, then it acts as a path separator. A common example of this is found in this ball machine at the beginning separating the first 2 tracks.


(Pictures: mathsboy314Sandroknexmaster, Sorunome, collinjo12)

Size Selector

KneXtreme.jpg
In KneXtreme's ball machine Copper, a track is wide enough that larger balls roll over it while regular balls fall through. This is useful is you have both types of balls but only one can be used in the lift/element you're building.

Tracks: 2
Height: tilt for momentum (+1 blue rod in one track)
Instructions: Just see the picture

That's It!

FD1G8GJGV0KKL1U_LARGE.jpg
That's all I can think of. If you have any more path separators, better pictures, names or details for them, leave them in the comments and I'll add them.

Happy Knexing!