Realistic-Looking Mushroom Meringue Cookies

by adamandjilltodd in Cooking > Cookies

180 Views, 5 Favorites, 0 Comments

Realistic-Looking Mushroom Meringue Cookies

Capture.PNG
Screenshot 2025-12-29 151541.png

Salutations!

Here you'll find an accessible recipe and tutorial to make your own realistic-looking mushroom meringue cookies.

Don't let the toadstool-esque appearance fool you- the crisp, melt-in-your-mouth meringue cookie balances with a rich chocolate glaze to create one delectable desert.

These are perfect for decorating cakes (they would absolutely shine on a yule log!), but they are scrumptious enough to stand all on their own too.

Supplies

Screenshot 2025-12-29 154008.png

Ingredients:

  1. 2 egg whites
  2. 1/4 teaspoon cream of tartar
  3. 1/2 cup sugar
  4. 1 tsp. flavouring (optional)
  5. approximately 1/3 cup milk chocolate chips
  6. white decorating frosting
  7. just a little bit of cocoa powder or espresso powder for sprinkling

Supplies:

  1. Basic baking and decorating utensils

Prepare Your Baking Sheet and Preheat Your Oven

  1. Spread a baking sheet with parchment paper, and set it aside until baking time.


  1. Preheat your oven to 210 degrees Fahrenheit.

Begin to Whip the Egg Whites

Screenshot 2025-12-29 154726.png
  1. Beat the whites until they are very frothy.

Beat in the Cream of Tartar

Screenshot 2025-12-29 155011.png
Screenshot 2025-12-29 155053.png
  1. Mix in the cream of tartar, and continue beating.
  2. Here is where you'll also add flavouring, if using.

Continue Beating Until Soft Peaks Form

Screenshot 2025-12-29 155516.png
  1. Time may vary, but you can expect it to take several minutes

Slowly Mix in the Sugar

Screenshot 2025-12-29 155323.png

Bit by bit, beat in the sugar. You want to be careful that you don't deflate the egg whites as you do this.

Continue Beating Until Stiff Peaks Form

Screenshot 2025-12-29 155729.png
  1. Meringue can be a little difficult when it comes to getting the consistency right, so be careful and stick with it.

Note~ it doesn't have to be stiff enough to hold the bowl upside down without anything falling out, but you do want it nice and thick.

Fill Your Piping Bag and Begin to Pipe the Mushroom

Screenshot 2025-12-29 160511.png
Screenshot 2025-12-29 160736.png
  1. For each mushroom, you need 1 top and 2 stem halves, so make sure you keep count.
  2. Make domed circles for the tops, and oblong teardrop shapes for the pairs of stem halves.
  3. Don't worry if you make a mistake- wild mushrooms don't grow perfectly symmetrical, so a crooked stem or bumpy top will make it look more natural and realistic.

Sprinkle the Tops With a Little Cocoa Powder

Screenshot 2025-12-29 161028.png
  1. Sprinkle the tops (not the stems) with just a little cocoa powder. Too much will cause the meringue to stay soft and jiggly, so use a light hand.

Bake for 45-50 Minutes

  1. Pop your meringue into the oven to bake until fairly hard, which will take about 45 minutes. Time can vary depending on how big or small you make your mushrooms.

Melt Your Chocolate

  1. While the meringue is baking, melt your chocolate.

Let the Cookies Cool

  1. You don't want them to fall apart, so give them just a few minutes to cool.

Assemble

Screenshot 2025-12-29 162129.png
Screenshot 2025-12-29 162319.png
Screenshot 2025-12-29 162455.png
Screenshot 2025-12-29 162513.png
Screenshot 2025-12-29 162725.png
Screenshot 2025-12-29 162845.png
Screenshot 2025-12-29 163007.png

This is a messy process but not hard. It's important to be delicate, since meringue is fragile.


  1. Very carefully, take a butter knife (or a similar tool) and carve a small hole in the bottom/flat side of a mushroom top.
  2. Take a pair of stem halves, and stick the flat sides together using a little white frosting.
  3. Dip the bottom/flat side of the mushroom top in the melted chocolate.
  4. Dip the top of the stem in the melted chocolate.
  5. Carefully insert the stem into the hole of the top part.

Finished!

Screenshot 2025-12-29 163444.png
Screenshot 2025-12-29 163418.png
Screenshot 2025-12-29 163347.png
Screenshot 2025-12-29 163306.png
Screenshot 2025-12-29 163327.png

These fun-guys (ba-dum-tss) are finished!

Now you know how to make some marvellous (and delicious) meringue mushroom cookies.