Fix a Broken Woodworking Vice

by mikeandmertle in Workshop > Tools

378 Views, 1 Favorites, 0 Comments

Fix a Broken Woodworking Vice

Broken Vice - Cover.png
20240405_180233.jpg
20240405_180200.jpg
20240406_155331.jpg
FFE62C7LUWOIZN2.jpg
F1Y5SB3LUWOIZMA.jpg
Sears Craftsman Woodworkers Vise 391.5195_0001.jpg

I recently came across an old Hercules Woodworking Vice. This thing is massive with an impressive jaw width, even bigger than my good old Record No.52 1/2.

Unfortunately the 'Drag bar' or 'Screw Bracket' was broken! Since it's cast iron it's not an easy thing to weld up, especially since I don't have a welder. I'd love to be able to braze this up one day, but for now, let's just fix the thing.

As part of this fix, I'm going to be repainting the vise, but I'm not going to focus on this for this instructable. I just want to show you how to duplicate a broken part.

Supplies

  • Some scrap steel or offcuts
  • 2 Bolts
  • Glue (5 minute epoxy)
  • Photocopier
  • A glue stick
  • An M6 or similar size thread tap and tap wrench
  • Centre Punch
  • Drill (drill press recommended)
  • Large drill bits or step drill
  • Round metal file
  • Drum sanding bit for drill
  • Scrap piece of think board
  • Scissors
  • Angle grinder with cut-off disc or hacksaw.

Make a Pattern for the Part

20240406_081325.jpg
20240405_073910.jpg
20240406_081340.jpg
20240406_081739.jpg

As with most replacement parts it's very important that it fits correctly for whatever you are fixing to work. Not all of us have access to CNC machines to make everything perfectly. So let's do this the cheap and easy way.

Start by gluing the broken part together as best you can, in my case it was easier to glue the drag bar onto an offcut of some thin MDF board. Now use a photocopier to make a perfect template of the part, you may need to adjust the copier's brightness settings.

Cut out the template of the part using scissors and glue this onto a piece of metal bar.

Drill the Holes

20240406_082701.jpg
20240406_083502.jpg
20240406_082034.jpg
20240406_083746.jpg

Use a centre punch to mark the centres of the holes, now using a smaller drill bit drill a pilot hole through the steel.

Measure the diameter of the holes an slowly drill these to the correct size, use some oil to lubricate the drillbit and avoid overheating it. I didn't have a bit big enough for the two outside holes so had to use a file and step drill to get it up to size. I ended up using a sanding wheel on the drill to take the holes up to the final size.

Cut the Parts to Size

20240406_143816.jpg
20240406_152434.jpg

I realised the dragbar didn't need to have a complex shape and instead marked out a simple design and cut this out using an angle grinder and cutoff wheel. I then finished this off with a sander belt.

One complexity with this part is that I didn't have any steel thick enough and two of the holes needed to only go halfway through. So I just got a second piece of scrap and using the first half as a stencil traced out the size, then cut and ground this as well.

Joining the Two Halves

20240406_152115.jpg
20240406_154721.jpg
20240406_153722.jpg
20240406_152224.jpg
20240406_153406.jpg

To join the two parts together I just drilled a couple of holes through both parts and then taped the first part. Then I used some lock-tight on the bolts and screwed them together. If you don't have a tap you can just bolt it together using a hex nut.

I then drilled centre hole all the way through and gave the completed part a final grid down so the two sides were flush.

Test Fit

20240406_155117.jpg
20240406_201520.jpg

Now test that everything fits and the vise operated correctly. You can stop here if you want or go on and paint everything up so it looks nice.

Clean and Paint Everything (optional)

20240411_163034.jpg
20240411_163041.jpg
20240412_123739.jpg
20240412_123744.jpg

I cleaned all the parts down and stripped the old paint off. Once all the parts were prepared I primed them and gave them a few coats of paint. I also used a wire wheel to polish the handle and guide rods.

Now I put everything back together, gave it an oil up and it's almost ready to go.

Assemble Everything

20240413_170204.jpg
20240413_170119.jpg

Now put everything back together, and the vice is fully operational.